Every year, somewhere around the time the pumpkins disappear and the Christmas trees start showing up, sellers begin asking:
“Should we just take the house off the market until after the holidays?”
And I understand why.
You’re trying to decorate.
Family is coming.
The kids are home.
There are presents everywhere.
Your dining room has temporarily become an Amazon distribution center.
And now somebody wants to schedule a showing at 6:15 PM on December 23.
😂
Taking the house off the market until January can sound very appealing.
But before you pull the listing, there’s something important to consider:
The holidays don’t automatically make it a bad time to sell a house.
In fact, depending on your situation, staying on the market may actually work in your favor.
Yes, There May Be Fewer Buyers
Let’s get this part out of the way.
Buyer activity can slow during the holidays.
People travel.
Schedules get busy.
Kids are out of school.
There are parties, shopping, family commitments and approximately 4,000 other things competing for everyone’s attention.
Some buyers will decide:
“We’ll start looking again after New Year’s.”
That’s real.
But there’s another side to it.
The Buyers Who ARE Looking May Have a Reason
Think about the person scheduling a showing three days before Christmas.
They’re probably not doing it because they ran out of holiday activities.
😂
Holiday buyers may be shopping because they:
- Need to relocate
- Have a lease ending
- Have already sold another home
- Need more space
- Want to move before a particular date
- Have a life change creating a deadline
- Simply found the right house and don’t want to wait
Not every holiday buyer is highly motivated.
But someone carving time out of a packed December schedule to tour your house may be a buyer worth accommodating.
You May Also Have Less Competition
This is the part sellers sometimes forget.
If some homeowners take their properties off the market for the holidays—or wait until spring to list—buyers who remain active may have fewer homes to choose from.
That can be helpful.
Instead of being one of 14 similar homes a buyer is considering, maybe you’re one of six.
So while the buyer pool can shrink…
the competition can shrink too.
That’s why I don’t make the decision based solely on the calendar.
I want to look at what is actually happening in your price range and your area.
“But I Don’t Want People in My House During Christmas.”
Fair.
That is a completely legitimate consideration.
Selling a house is inconvenient.
There’s no inspirational Realtor quote that’s going to change that.
😂
Keeping a house show-ready is already work.
Add:
Christmas decorations.
Presents.
Kids home from school.
Family visiting.
Pets.
Holiday cooking.
And suddenly every showing request feels personal.
But staying on the market doesn’t necessarily mean you surrender control of your entire holiday season.
We can talk about showing parameters.
Maybe there are certain dates when showings aren’t available.
Maybe you require reasonable notice.
Maybe Christmas Eve and Christmas Day are blocked entirely.
Maybe family arrives for four days and we plan around that.
There is a difference between:
Making the house reasonably accessible to buyers
and
Allowing real estate to take over Christmas.
Should You Decorate a House That’s for Sale?
Yes.
You are still allowed to have Christmas.
😂
I don’t need you sitting in an undecorated beige box staring sadly at one tasteful pinecone because your house is listed.
Decorate.
Just remember that buyers still need to be able to see the house.
A Christmas tree is fine.
A Christmas tree occupying 73% of the living room and requiring buyers to turn sideways to reach the kitchen?
Maybe not.
Keep walkways clear.
Don’t cover important features.
Avoid making rooms feel smaller.
And remember that listing photos may live online longer than the decorations stay in your house.
If we’re taking new professional photos in December, we should think about whether we want the property permanently represented online as Christmas House 2026.
A little seasonal warmth?
Lovely.
Santa’s workshop?
Let’s discuss.
😂
What About Taking It Off and Starting Fresh in January?
This is where sellers sometimes think they’ve discovered a strategy:
“We’ll take it off for a few weeks and then it’ll look like a brand-new listing in January.”
Not necessarily.
Listing history doesn’t simply vanish because we take a holiday break.
Agents and buyers may still be able to see previous listing activity and history.
So I would not recommend withdrawing a property solely because we’re trying to fool the market into thinking it has never been listed.
That’s not a strategy.
What can make sense is taking a deliberate pause because we’re going to use that time to change something meaningful.
Maybe we’re:
- Making repairs
- Painting
- Improving presentation
- Replacing flooring
- Updating photography
- Repositioning the price
- Changing the marketing strategy
That’s different.
Now we’re not just disappearing for December.
We’re preparing for a better relaunch.
If the House Has Already Been Sitting, That’s a Different Conversation
This is where I want sellers to be particularly careful.
Suppose your house has already been listed for 75 days.
Activity has slowed.
You’ve had plenty of showings but no offer.
And now you’re thinking:
“Let’s just take it off until January.”
Okay.
But January isn’t going to magically solve whatever prevented the house from selling in October and November.
If the problem is price…
January still knows.
😂
If the photos aren’t helping…
January still knows.
If buyers consistently object to something about the condition…
January still knows.
Before we pause the listing, I want to understand why it hasn’t sold.
If we’re going to relaunch, let’s actually give the market a reason to look at the house differently.
Don’t Automatically Wait for Spring Either
This one comes up all the time.
“Wouldn’t we get more money if we just waited until spring?”
Maybe.
But that’s not guaranteed.
Spring may bring more buyers.
It can also bring more sellers.
More listings.
More competition.
And nobody knows today exactly what mortgage rates, inventory, buyer demand or your personal circumstances will look like several months from now.
Waiting can absolutely be the right decision.
But I want that decision based on your actual goals, not a generic rule that says:
“Nobody buys houses during the holidays.”
People buy houses during the holidays.
They buy houses in January.
They buy houses in July.
They buy houses during football season in Georgia, which frankly feels more disruptive than Christmas.
😂
Your Timeline Matters More Than the Holiday Calendar
This is the part I care about most.
Why are you selling?
Do you need to move?
Have you already bought another house?
Are you relocating?
Are you trying to be somewhere before the beginning of the year?
Can you comfortably carry the house for several more months?
Would waiting create another problem?
Or are you completely flexible?
The right decision for a seller who needs to move by January 15 is very different from the right decision for someone who says:
“If it sells, great. If not, we’ll try again in March.”
Real estate strategy should fit your life.
Not the other way around.
What If You Get an Offer During the Holidays?
Then we evaluate the offer exactly like we would any other time of year.
Don’t automatically think:
“They’re the only buyer. We better take whatever they offer.”
No.
And don’t automatically think:
“It’s the holidays. They must be desperate. We have all the leverage.”
Also no.
😂
We look at:
- Purchase price
- Financing
- Seller-paid closing costs
- Due diligence
- Closing date
- Contingencies
- Requested repairs or concessions
- Your estimated net
- Your timeline
- The strength of the buyer
The calendar doesn’t replace the math.
One Holiday Advantage Nobody Talks About: Your House Can Feel Like Home
There’s something about a house during the holidays.
Warm lights.
A wreath on the door.
A tree in the living room.
A fire going if you have a fireplace.
The house can feel especially inviting.
And buyers aren’t only purchasing bedrooms and bathrooms.
They’re imagining:
Could this be our home?
Could our tree go there?
Could everyone fit around this table?
Could the kids come down these stairs Christmas morning?
Could we host Thanksgiving here?
Used thoughtfully, the holidays can actually help buyers emotionally connect with a property.
We just don’t want to cross the line from:
warm and inviting
to
Santa Claus exploded in aisle seven at Hobby Lobby.
😂
So When WOULD I Consider Taking the House Off the Market?
There are situations where a holiday pause can make sense.
Your family genuinely needs the break
If staying listed will make the holidays miserable and your selling timeline is flexible, that’s worth considering.
The house needs work
If we’re already planning repairs or improvements, December may give us a useful window.
The current strategy clearly isn’t working
If the listing needs a substantial reset, we may be better served by fixing the underlying problem rather than limping through another month.
Showing access will be extremely limited
If buyers essentially can’t see the house for several weeks, we need to discuss whether remaining actively listed makes sense.
Your personal timeline changed
Maybe you no longer need—or want—to sell immediately.
That’s allowed too.
And When Would I Lean Toward Staying Listed?
If:
You’re motivated to sell.
The house is priced appropriately.
We’re still getting activity.
You can reasonably accommodate showings.
There are buyers searching in your price range.
Inventory is limited among your direct competition.
Or taking the house off would simply delay a move you already know you need to make.
Then I would think very carefully before disappearing from the market just because Thanksgiving and Christmas are coming.
Don’t Make the Decision Based on What Everybody Else Does
Your neighbor may take their house off the market.
Your cousin may tell you nobody buys houses in December.
Somebody on Facebook may confidently announce that you should never list between Halloween and Valentine’s Day.
Facebook also has people who believe the HOA can legally take your firstborn child because your trash can stayed out until Thursday.
😂
We’re not building your real estate strategy around that.
We’re looking at:
Your house.
Your competition.
Your market.
Your timeline.
Your finances.
Your tolerance for showings.
And your goals.
Then we decide.
A Front Porch Rachel Thought
The holidays already come with enough pressure.
I don’t think selling your house needs to become another arbitrary rule you’re supposed to follow.
There isn’t a magical date when buyers disappear.
And there isn’t a magical January morning when every house suddenly becomes easier to sell.
Sometimes staying listed through the holidays makes perfect sense.
Sometimes taking a break is exactly what a family needs.
And sometimes a temporary pause gives us the opportunity to fix a strategy that wasn’t working anyway.
The important part is knowing why you’re making the decision.
Don’t take your house off the market because:
“That’s just what people do at Christmas.”
And don’t stay on the market because:
“Rachel said holiday buyers are serious.”
😂
Let’s look at your specific situation.
Then we make the decision that gives you the best chance of getting where you’re trying to go.
Because the goal isn’t simply to keep a sign in the yard.
The goal is to get you moved.
Real Estate. Real Life. Rachel.
Leave a Reply